Home » Posts tagged 'Craig Martin'

Tag Archives: Craig Martin

Essentialism and Female Golfers

When watching pro-golfers play a match, you can sometimes hear the players yell “FORE,” which gives warning to spectators ahead that their ball is coming towards them. This is very important, so no one is injured while watching this game. This is the golfers or even their cadies (but mainly the golfer) job to give the warning. Which brings me to Saturday, September 14th, 2019, pro-golfer Lexi Thompson had just hit from the tee box, and her ball was drifting to the right when a spectator yelled for her, “FORE right!” which Thompson responded with, “Wasn’t that bad” and proceeded to glare at the spectator. Commentators were laughing and joking at this interaction while the golf channel tweeting out:

While this may be a funny moment to some, I wasn’t necessarily thinking that. I played golf for four years for McDaniel College, and I know how Thompson feels having someone not playing speak for them. It also got me thinking, “would this happen if it was Tiger Woods or Rory Mcllroy?” Thompson is 24 and has been playing golf professionally since she was 16 having 14 professional wins under her belt. Looking at some of the comments left on this tweet, we see people (men mainly) criticize Thompson for not yelling “FORE,” one comment read, “Yeah. Let a it hit a spectator in the head but let’s spare Lexi’s feelings”.  Others called her arrogant for not yelling fore and saying she has a fragile ego for the comment.

 But I ask again if this was Tiger Woods or Rory McIlroy, would someone have yelled “FORE” for them? I don’t think so, and that is because they are both men in a heavily male-dominated sport with titles under their belts. Women did not have a golf organization in the United States until 1917 with the Women’s Tournament Committee of the United States Golf Association (USGA). The first professional female golfer was Helen Hicks in 1934, who was one of the founding members of the LPGA. Babe Zaharias, a former Olympian, would play in the Los Angeles Open in 1938, which was a PGA event, and no woman before he had tried to play against professional male golfers.

Playing golf as a female athlete is challenging because it is such a male-dominated sport, and you are often faced with criticism that your male counterpart probably wouldn’t face. “Be happy with the score you got. Don’t be so emotional over that putt.” Are some things I personally have heard from some male coaches. The pressure of winning or doing well in a match in this sport is immense, and if you are having a lousy hole (had too many strokes hitting or putting) or just hitting it to the right and someone speaks for you, you would probably glare too. The pressure is worse for female athletes because of the societal standards of being perfect or as good as the male counterpart.

 Looking at Craig Martin’s book A Critical Introduction to The Study of Religion, he breaks down how society creates categories we are placed into. Martin explains this in a simple break down:

Applying this to Thompson or any female golfer, we see a societal structure that produces stereotypes.

This break down can apply to other things, of course, because it highlights how society puts us into boxes and the formation of stereotypes. Throughout my time playing colligate golf, I had an opposing teams’ coach continuously tell me how to do things that I knew, or he would call me sweetheart or darling even though he knew my name. From my own experience, this coach maybe unknowingly had boxed me into a stereotype in which I couldn’t play golf and had to be taken care of like a child. But how does one handle these situations? Thompson glared at the man who yelled for her, my coach finally had a conversation with this other coach, so I had an ally.

At the end of the day, though, female athletes are put into these boxes and slowly have been breaking out, showing their male counterparts and society that yes, we are female athletes, but that’s just it; we are athletes. And that is the most important thing here that athletic performance should not focus on gender. When discussing this with a friend who knew nothing about golf, his first question was, “Wait; there is a separate league for female golfers? Why are they not in the same league?” It’s a good question that I do not have an answer for. Maybe someday there will only be one league for golfers, and perhaps eventually, female golfers won’t have others speak for them when their shot is a little off to the right.

css.php